Airports & comparison
JFK vs LaGuardia vs Newark: Where to Rent a Car
Which NYC airport is best (and cheapest) to rent a car from?
- Compare 500+ trusted suppliers
- Free cancellation on most bookings
- No hidden fees · 24/7 multilingual support
All three New York-area airports have full rental operations, but they differ on price, distance to Manhattan, and which trips they suit. Here's how to choose.
Quick comparison
The short version:
- Newark (EWR): often the cheapest, best for New Jersey and points south/west
- LaGuardia (LGA): closest to Midtown, best for domestic trips
- JFK: widest international supplier choice, great for Long Island and the East End
Don't forget tolls and one-way fees
Newark's lower base rates can be partly offset by tunnel tolls and congestion pricing into the city. All three support one-way rentals (pick up at the airport, drop off in the city or another airport), sometimes with a one-way fee. Compare the all-in price, not just the headline rate.
FAQs
Newark (EWR) frequently has the lowest base rates, though tolls into the city can offset some savings. Compare all three airports for your exact dates, including any one-way fee, before booking.